Tab Earley

29 March, 2011

why i still don’t like self-publishing

Filed under: publishing — Tab Earley @ 10:15 am
Tags: , ,

I really think this little incident serves as a good specimen of why I still can’t get on board with DIY publishing. Not to say that professional authors don’t engage in the same kind of tantrum, because they do. However, at least professional authors have gone through the process of querying, getting an agent, getting published, the sort of gruntwork that it seems many self-published writers can’t be bothered to do.

I’m sure there are people who self-publish who have a lot of talent and are just tired of the repetitive and disappointing process of querying and rejection. (There are also people in various industries who do it for various logistical reasons, but I’m talking about fiction here.) It can be gutting to be told your work isn’t good enough, and going the self-pub route isn’t necessarily an indication that your work is tripe. I think it’ll be interesting to see how this sort of thing evolves as the publishing industry continues to falter and big-name booksellers continue to go out of business.

However. The link above unfortunately illustrates all of the familiar touchstones of the self-published writer: badly-written prose, little or no editing, tantrums over reviews that dare to mention those two things, and an ego in inverse proportion to the writer’s talent. To be blunt, I thought the reviewer was a lot kinder than he could have (maybe should have) been. It’s hard to find nice things to say about work that an author clearly couldn’t be bothered to proofread properly, so kudos to him for even trying. I certainly wouldn’t.

Unfortunately, the writer vomiting up adolescent entitlement all over his post lacks the same sense of perspective. This is why she hasn’t been published, and why she probably never will. Not because she lacks talent– the concept is subjective at the best of times– but because she lacks so many other things.

One thing I’ve had to learn myself is that writing is not easy. It’s not just a matter of sitting down, typing out some stuff, and then slapping it up for other people to read and waiting for the adulation to roll in. It requires something more than just raw talent: it requires work and perspective. I have trouble with that first one, which is probably why I haven’t been published myself. Writers are lazy people, and we have to fight that natural predilection for sloth in order to get anywhere.

I do, however, think I have a good sense of perspective. I knew for a very long time that my work wasn’t good enough for publication, and only now that I feel it is will I submit it. When it’s ready (and it isn’t yet), I will happily send it off to a publisher or agent. And if that publisher or agent doesn’t like it, doesn’t think it’s right for them, or just isn’t interested, I will be glad to take whatever feedback I can get, process it, and then send the work out again.  Wash, rinse, repeat. And if it turns out that I discover a way to do self-publishing that won’t eat up every single hour of my day with publicity, social networking, and admin (leaving little time for actual writing), I might do so.

Being, as I said, a lazy person, I am content to let the publisher/agent do as much of the legwork as they will do. That’s why we have them: they do things like setting up book signings and interviews and sending out review copies so that we don’t have to. Even successful self-publishers make the jump to traditional publishing when they can. They have connections that we as writers don’t have, publicity machines that we could never hope to equal. So I’m quite happy to do things the old-fashioned way for the time being.


Leave a Comment »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

%d bloggers like this: